Excellent John, Okafor is a great athlete.
I have worked with quite a few taller than me
The thing about athletics is the definition of athlete is so broad.
For example you can take a great athlete and put a KB in his or her hands and all of a sudden they may not look so athletic.
In the case of Gonzales, he is a special athlete and out of all athletes, a pro baseball guy who is .300 + hitter has genetic gift of hand-eye. This separates them from all other athletes in my book. It is said that to hit a major league fastball is the hardest skill to execute in all of sports. I think it may be because many things can be trained, but that is a skill that one must be born with and no amount of training will enable the less gifted to see that ball.
Gonzales, he pretty much could do everything very quickly. Not perfect KB technique, but he could see the bell and hit the bell, so to speak. He was juggling within the first minute of touching it and he did not drop one juggle, so yeah way above the curve.
I would not expect a basketball player to be able to pick the basics up as quickly.